Tax Residency and PoEM in India: An Overview

In India, tax residency and the Place of Effective Management (PoEM) are key concepts in determining tax obligations and addressing issues like double taxation or tax evasion. To comply with Indian tax laws and avoid unintended tax liabilities, companies must understand the two concepts and carefully evaluate their management operations and structure.

Tax residency and the Place of Effective Management (PoEM) are crucial for determining tax obligations and avoiding issues like double taxation or tax evasion. PoEM is a globally recognized criterion for establishing the tax residency of companies incorporated in foreign jurisdictions. Its significance lies in its role in determining a company’s tax obligations, particularly in the context of India’s tax treaties, which aim to avoid double taxation.

For Indian businesses operating abroad, PoEM plays a crucial role in determining tax residency when strategic and key decisions for these entities are made within India. This determination is guided by the principles outlined in the Income Tax Act, 1961, and detailed instructions from the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT).

Tax residency and PoEM

The Finance Act, 2015, redefined the residency rules for foreign companies under the Income Tax Act, 1961, Section 6(3), stating that a company will be deemed an Indian resident if:

1. It is incorporated in India, or
2. Its PoEM is located in India.

Find Business Support

Our corporate establishment and governance services ensure your business is set up efficiently and operates within requisite legal frameworks across Asia.

Tax residency determines where an individual or entity is considered a tax resident under the tax laws of a specific country. For individuals, it is typically based on the number of days they stay in a country during a financial year, while for corporations, it often depends on their place of incorporation or registration. Tax residency establishes the scope of taxation, including whether global income is taxable in the country of residence.

PoEM refers to the location where key management and commercial decisions essential for the entity’s overall operations are substantively made. It focuses on the substance of decision-making rather than the place of implementation. 

For example, deciding to establish a new manufacturing facility or discontinuing a major product line qualifies as a PoEM-related decision. The residential status, and consequently the PoEM, must be assessed annually. However, PoEM provisions do not apply to companies with annual turnover or gross receipts of INR 500 million (US$5.84 million) or less.

India guidelines for determining PoEM

The CBDT’s circular No. 6 of 2017 provides a structured framework for determining PoEM. The guidelines classify companies into the following categories:

1. Companies with active business outside India (ABOI): A company is considered to have an active business outside India if it meets the following criteria:

• Income composition: Passive income (e.g., royalties, dividends, interest, or rental income) constitutes 50 percent or less of total income.
• Assets: Less than 50 percent of the total assets are located in India. For depreciable assets, the average tax value at the beginning and end of the financial year is considered.
• Employees: Fewer than 50 percent of employees are located or resident in India. Employee count is averaged between the start and end of the financial year.
• Payroll expenses: Payroll costs for employees in India account for less than 50 percent of total payroll expenditure.

If these conditions are met, the company’s PoEM is presumed to be outside India.

2. Companies not meeting the ABOI criteria: For companies failing the ABOI conditions, PoEM determination involves:

• Key management test: Identify individuals or groups responsible for the company’s key management and commercial decisions. Determine the location where these decisions are made, prioritizing the site of decision-making over implementation.
• Head office test: The head office is the location where senior management primarily operates or convenes. For decentralized organizations, the head office is identified as the place where senior management gathers for critical decisions or where top executives (e.g., Managing Director) are based. In cases of significant decentralization, the head office location may be irrelevant in determining PoEM.

3. Miscellaneous factors: If PoEM cannot be clearly established through the above tests, secondary factors are considered, such as:

• The location of primary business activities.
• The place where accounting records are maintained.

Entities potentially impacted by the PoEM framework

The Place of Effective Management framework has significant implications for various entities, particularly concerning their tax obligations in India. These entities must meet the stipulated PoEM criteria to trigger tax liability in India. Examples of such entities include:

• Subsidiaries and joint ventures: Foreign subsidiaries or joint ventures of Indian parent companies, including those located in jurisdictions such as Singapore.
• Software companies: Indian businesses with operations or subsidiaries overseas.
• Investment firms: Offshore investment entities established to leverage tax treaty benefits.
• Shell companies: Entities incorporated abroad but effectively managed and controlled from India.

Tax implications of PoEM

The tax obligations of a company are directly linked to its residency status.

• Resident companies: Taxed on their global income.
• Non-resident companies: Taxed only on income received, accrued, or arising in India.

Assessment process for PoEM

If an assessing officer determines that a foreign company should be classified as a resident based on PoEM, the following steps are mandatory:

1. Obtain prior approval from the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of Income-tax.
2. Provide the company with an opportunity to present its case before a final decision is made.

Aligning business operations with Indian tax law

Understanding the PoEM condition is essential because it directly impacts a company’s tax residency status, which determines its tax obligations. This concept is particularly relevant in today’s globalized economy, where businesses often operate across multiple jurisdictions. PoEM helps prevent tax evasion and ensures that companies pay taxes where their actual management and decision-making take place.

1. Tax residency determination: PoEM is a critical factor in establishing whether a foreign company is considered a resident for tax purposes in India. A company classified as a resident in India is subject to tax on its global income, whereas non-residents are taxed only on Indian-sourced income.
2. Compliance with Indian tax laws: Indian tax authorities use PoEM to ensure that companies with significant management and operational control in India fulfill their tax obligations. Understanding PoEM enables businesses to align their operations with legal requirements, reducing the risk of penalties or litigation.
3. Prevention of tax evasion: PoEM discourages practices such as incorporating shell companies in tax-friendly jurisdictions while effectively managing and controlling them from India. It helps curb treaty abuse and ensures that profits are taxed in the jurisdiction where substantive business activities occur.
4. Annual review requirements: Tax residency under PoEM is determined annually. This necessitates businesses to regularly evaluate their decision-making structures and activities to ensure compliance.

How does PoEM affect foreign businesses in India?

Find Business Support

How we help unlock your business potential in India

PoEM has significant implications for foreign businesses operating in India, particularly those with cross-border operations.

1. Taxation of worldwide income: If a foreign company’s PoEM is deemed to be in India, it becomes a resident for tax purposes and is liable to pay tax on its worldwide income. This may increase the tax burden, particularly for businesses structured to minimize global tax liabilities.
2. Increased compliance requirements: Companies must maintain comprehensive documentation of where key management and commercial decisions are made. This includes records of board meetings, financial transactions, and decision-making processes to substantiate their PoEM.
3. Impact on business structures: Businesses with decentralized operations may need to reassess their management structures to avoid triggering PoEM in India. This can influence decisions regarding the location of key personnel, board meetings, and executive committees.
4. Implications for multinational entities: Subsidiaries or joint ventures of Indian parent companies, investment firms, and offshore entities managed from India can be classified as residents. Such classification can nullify the tax benefits of operating in low-tax jurisdictions and lead to higher taxation and reporting requirements in India.
5. Regulatory scrutiny: PoEM provisions increase regulatory oversight, particularly for companies that operate in jurisdictions perceived as tax havens. Businesses must ensure transparency in their management practices to avoid scrutiny from Indian tax authorities.

Conclusion

Understanding PoEM is vital for businesses with foreign operations or cross-border structures to effectively navigate India’s tax landscape. By accurately identifying and managing PoEM-related risks, companies can optimize their tax strategies, ensure regulatory compliance, and maintain operational efficiency. For foreign businesses in India, aligning management structures with PoEM guidelines can help avoid unintended tax liabilities and preserve the benefits of global operations.

(US$1 = INR 85.60)

• Previous Article India’s Economic Report Card for 2024: FDI, Trade, and Infrastructure Growth
• Next Article SEBI Unveils Integrated Filing Framework for Listed Entities, Mandates Secretarial Audits